Research
Secondary research
Competitive analysis
Feb 2024
Project background: Research for an application that allows users to make plans, generate gift ideas, share budget expenses, and create wish lists.
Research goals: Competition analysis. Making a user friendly, easy to use app.
- What do the users like and don’t like about the existing applications?
- What are they missing?
Wishlists - online wishlist
Metrics: 5.0 rating, 907 reviews, 50k downloads, not many written reviews
4 stars, 8 February 2024
It's a great app. Beautiful layout and easy navigation. There's no annoying ads which is a huge plus. Almost perfect however. It's quite irritating that it's easy to swipe off the list you are editing and all the info you typed in are all gone. Personally I swap between two apps on the phone to copy paste the info from the web to the app and it's very easy to accidently close the list I was editing. There is no auto save so everything will just be gone.
5 stars, 10 February 2024
It's a great app with great designs and is very useful. There aren't many apps that offer wishlists where you can also add the pricing, picture, link etc. I'm extremely satisfied with it, it has everything I've been looking for to verbalize my wishes and make a list of my priorities. One thing I might add is when I accidentally pushed the check mark button on one of the products I added, it couldn't be undone anymore. I had to write out the wish again, tbh it was a bit troublesome. Otherwise✨✨
Users like: layout and easy navigation; no annoying ads; adding photos, pricing, links.
Users don't like: the app doesn't work, it's easy to swipe off the list you are editing.
Missing: Not implied in reviews.
Giftster - Wish List Registry
Metrics: 3.0 rating, 643 reviews, 100k downloads
3 stars, 27 December 2022
The app is ok for basics but it seriously needs some attention. The interface feels like it hasn't been updated since 2012, and it can be a bit confusing to navigate if you're not familiar with it. The ability for the app to fetch the data is great but it lacks the functionality of alot of other similar apps such as sharing links from sites or other apps to this app via the inbuilt Android share tool or getting regular updates on prices of items to let you know when it's on special.
3 stars, 26 December 2018
Very handy app to have. Would be great if there was an option for the recipient of a gift to re-add that same item back onto their list once recieved or an "ongoing" flag that doesn't allow it to show as purchased on your list. Sometimes you want things on your wishlist that you use all the time, like gift cards for favourite restaurants or favourite personal care products. But if somebody reserves it, then it greys out to the rest of the group. To add it back on, you have to start from scratch.
4 stars, August 14, 2020
Very useful. It's the best gift app I've found so far. I just wish the UI was modern and attractive. Feels like I'm inside a crumpled and ripped paper bag. Gallery views, instead of long lists, would be nice too. That said, I've tried other gift apps with a nicer looking interface and walked away sorely disappointed in their functionality. In my book, function beats form every time. If the developers improved the app design without compromising functionality, this would be a 5 star ⭐ winner!
Users like: handy, mark items as bought, a lot of options of a wish
Users don't like: graphic, outdated UI, confusing navigation
Missing: a function of "android share", keeping the item on a person's list even if someone already bought it for them (gift cards); Gallery views instead of long lists
Metrics: 3.4 rating, 724 reviews, 100k downloads
3 stars, 22 January 2024
It's OK, but I wish you could just import your whole wishlist or basket in one go. I have so much saved on my wishlists on sites like Amazon already that it makes no sense to upload here one by one.
3 stars, 27 December 2023
It's so good!! But there is eo much issues that made me mad, I can't even explain, and there is way too much buttons to press just to add something on the wish list.
4 stars, 25 November 2023
Love the app. It's super easy to use you don't have to pay anything. As soon as you get to the wishlist part you know everything. No tutorials needed. The only thing I don't like is the button is really small when you're adding it to your wishlist.
5 stars, 4 November 2023
Literally all you have to do is put the link for the item in and it puts the details and picture for you. Also you can name and put a picture for your wishlist. This is super accessible and very easy to use.
Users like: copy and paste link function, option to reserve a gift
Users don't like: the app is slow or crushes; the navigation of creating an item is confusing and complicated
Missing: importing a basket in one go as a list
Users desire easy navigation with a modern look, while also wanting numerous options to describe their wish. Desired functions to consider include:
- Copying and pasting a link to create a wish
- Reserving a gift
- Importing a basket as a list in one go
- Android share functionality
- Keeping an item on a person's list even if someone has already bought it for them (gift cards)
- Saving the process on the go.